
Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol” is perhaps the most famous fictional Christmas story of all time — the story of a cruel, cold man’s encounter with yuletide spirits who change his life.
This story has been retold countless times, from faithful adaptations to pastiches to parodies. So what kind of adaptation can you expect in “A Muppet Christmas Carol,” which populates Dickens’ classic tale with Jim Henson’s fuzzy puppets? A surprisingly faithful adaptation that trims off a few of the darker edges, but carries the viewers along with a strong performance by Michael Caine and some truly charming songs.
Gonzo (claiming to be Charles Dickens) and his companion Rizzo serve as the narrators/Greek chorus, following and explaining the action as it unfolds. The story: the cold and cruel Ebenezer Scrooge (Caine), who sneers at Christmas, is visited by the ghosts of his old business partners Marley and Marley (Statler and Waldorf), who predict that he will be visited by three spirits on Christmas Eve. If he wants to escape the Marleys’ fate — chained by their evil deeds — he must learn from the spirits.
And over the course of three hours that night, Scrooge is visited by the three spirits — the ethereal Ghost of Christmas Past, the merry and jovial Ghost of Christmas Present, and the silent and sinister Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come. As Scrooge is shown his own past Christmases, the people he knows, and the world that will unfold if he does not change his ways, his cold heart begins to change.
There are two layers to the “Muppet Christmas Carol” — at its core, the story is a pretty faithful adaptation of Charles Dickens’ novel. As the movie is aimed at kids, the sociological aspects of Dickens’ own time are mostly trimmed out (except for the “surplus population” line), but the script is peppered by lines taken from the original novel, and it maintains a certain 19th-century flavor even in the lines conjured up for the movie.
And it doesn’t shy away from some of the darker elements, such as Tim’s impending death, a bunny child shivering in the snow, or the Ghost of Christmas yet to come — a grey-cloaked phantom with long deathly-blue hands and a yawning black maw for a face.
But in an odd way, Gonzo and Rizzo serving as a narrative frame makes the whole thing feel more like a story, and less like events that are truly happening. And the story is further softened by a second layer — a layer of Muppety goodness. This world of Ebenezer Scrooge is occupied by muppets, ranging from singing fruit to a sinister spider, from the floating baby-faced Spirit of Christmas Past to the familiar faces of Kermit and Miss Piggy (who play the timid Bob Cratchit and his feisty wife).
Gonzo and Rizzo add plenty of comic relief as they follow Scrooge through time (Rizzo gets frozen, used as a rag, crashes through some woods, and lands on a hot goose), breaking the fourth wall merrily at every possible opportunity. And tthe faithful-sounding dialogue is peppered with funny asides and classic Muppets fare (“It is a tradition for me to make a little speech.” “And it’s a tradition for us to take a little nap”).
Michael Caine does a thoroughly solid job as Ebenezer Scrooge, giving a performance as earnest as if he were working with human players instead of puppets — his transition from icily, angrily cold to merry and kind is a bit abrupt, but the performance itself is quite good. And the performances for the Muppets are all quite good — the Gonzo performance is especially good, as he often has to switch between goofy weirdness and a solemn narrative presence.
It may not technically be the most faithful adaptation, but “A Muppet Christmas Carol” is about the best way to introduce children to this classic story — with singing, puppets and festive spirit.








